(19:59:28) Brokk: Morning. I added some points to my comment in world dev and I had a question about their interactions with Tian Xia.
(19:59:46) Brokk: Or rather I have a question.
(19:59:59) Brokk: How are you?
(20:01:04) Darrik: Doing alright. But I'm guessing that wasn't the world dev question
(20:01:19) Brokk:

(20:02:56) Brokk: If the idea for their quarries, etc pans out, would the empire allow one such construction to exist within their borders for easier access to the shaped materials?
(20:03:30) Darrik: brb - 5m
(20:04:54) Brokk: A potential rp could centre around establishing such a place.
(20:04:57) Brokk: Kk
(20:05:17) Brokk: Or negotiations for such.
(20:07:29) Darrik: That's a question that kind of puts the cart before the horse.
A better question to start with is this: how long have the Dar been interacting with the Empire of Tian Xia, and how integrated into the Empire are they likely to be?
(20:08:09) Brokk: I'm going with quite some time.
(20:09:39) Brokk: This would be the first proper attempt to negotiate for access beyond their lands. Before this they traded and more or less stayed put.
(20:11:05) Darrik: So the answer is: not bloody likely.
(20:11:10) Brokk: All subject to change but generally speaking, I'm aiming for them to have been trying for the better part of a century or so
(20:11:28) Brokk: Fair enough.
(20:11:46) Darrik: However, that answer is based on the notion that this would be their first attempt
(20:12:36) Darrik: The reason why I am fixated on the issue of Imperial Integration is because that is what determines how accepted a particular merchant might be in the heart of the Empire
(20:12:48) Brokk: Well it would be the first time that the notion wasn't rejected out of hand, let's say, but was being talked about.
(20:13:02) Darrik: And the question is also: why would they want a quarry away from home?
(20:13:16) Darrik: A lot of what you ask seems out of character for what you have described of the Dar thus far
(20:14:43) Darrik: I think the first foundation stone to lay is to iron out some details regarding their home first, and day to day life, and how they view the Empire in general.
Once that foundation is laid, we can more properly look at ways to build on that to create interchanging links between them and the empire over their history.
I'd also recommend a timeline
(20:14:49) Brokk: they are drawn to soft spots in the seal, and the druids believe that each quarry is like a bandaid healing the world.
(20:15:35) Darrik: That argument isn't going to convince any bureaucrat
(20:15:46) Darrik: This might help with the timeline:
http://www.tharshaddin.com/wiki/History_of_Tian_Xia
(20:16:21) Brokk: Again, just another mad notion. If it makes more sense to drop it, then I can do that too.
(20:16:56) Darrik: You need to first establish what their baseline relation with the empire is before embarking on anything else, if that makes sense
(20:17:05) Darrik: Create the setting first, then look into RP possibilities
(20:18:13) Darrik: Sure, keep RP ideas in mind as you create the setting - little details that you can potentially hook into as the impetus for an rp - but focus on getting the basics down first
(20:19:20) Darrik: Once there's basic information down, it then becomes a lot easier to start working on the finer details - all the little interconnections between the Dar and Tian Xia which can be slipped into a timeline or general information re: culture
(20:20:03) Darrik: Right now, every time we talk I get a very different picture of what the Dar are doing, and it makes it hard to give a concrete answer to anything, if that makes sense?
(20:20:53) Brokk: I was running with the idea that they have relatively few full time warriors, saving the quarry guards who are given to the druids as tribute and the vassals of each clan king. The rest would be farmers and craftsmen who only take up arms when called to the clan's or their families' defence.
(20:21:53) Darrik: Might I suggest doing a rewrite of your first post in the Dar thread so that there's a better description of that?
(20:22:15) Brokk: It does, but mostly I'm trying to figure out if the raw idea has potential so that I can whittle it down or if I need to scrap it entirely
(20:23:41) Darrik: Here's the thing: I can think of a dozen different ways of integrating the Dar into the Empire without a problem - unless my ideas clash directly with your creative vision. And until I see what your current view of the Dar is, after our discussions thus far, I'm kind of at an impasse when it comes to sharing those ideas
(20:24:50) Brokk: I'm willing to listen to anything, reall, but I understand that I can seem difficult, so I respect your candour.
(20:26:44) Brokk: I don't see them as warlike unless pushed to defend themselves. A lot of their conflict is pageantry to make one clan or another look good for the druids. If the druids were on side, basically, the rest would toe the line.
(20:26:54) Porter: Katona logs into the Chat.
(20:26:57) Porter: Katona has been logged out (Timeout).
(20:26:57) Porter: Katona logs into the Chat.
(20:27:00) Porter: Katona logs out of the Chat.
(20:27:13) Brokk: If that makes sense at all?
(20:27:18) Darrik: Whereas your initial description still says 'very warlike' thus my suggestions that you amend that initial description
(20:27:58) Darrik: If the Dar are not overly aggressive, more defending their lands if needed, then that's one major obstacle out of the way
(20:29:57) Brokk: Also, in terms of time, I'd prefer that they appeared in the aftermath of the Changers war, so either during the warring races period or shortly after the establishment of the tianlong dynasty.
(20:30:48) Porter: (359157) logs into the Chat.
(20:30:52) Darrik: The Imperial Consolidation period, then
(20:31:03) Porter: (359157) is now known as (bob).
(20:31:36) Darrik: Alright, this next bit is going to take me a small while to type, so please be patient with me. While I do, I highly recommend reading this section (and the rest of that page too)
http://www.tharshaddin.com/wiki/The_Im ... n_Tian_Xia
(20:32:36) Brokk: So for a long time there would have been little interest from either side in understanding one another.
(20:35:53) Porter: (tom) has been logged out (Timeout).
(20:41:04) Porter: (bob) has been logged out (Timeout).
(20:41:21) Darrik: The Tianlong approach to empire is very similar to what the Persian Empire was in our history: let the locals rule themselves with regards to local matters, but those regions still fall under the governance of the Empire when it comes to taxation, census, language, and laws.
The Empire overseas three main geographical areas, each with its own peculiarities: the northern provinces of the Xiongnu Steppes, Imperial Tian Xia (the heartlands), and the southern provinces of Nanyue (which are limited to a number of heavily militarised city-states north of a rather nasty jungle)
If the Dar have been around since the start, then it's likely that all the heaviest and bloodiest conflicts were taken care of during the Imperial Consolidation Period. With that in mind, if the Dar have been trading with the Empire for a few hundred years, speaking the language and abiding by the laws, providing census data and a token amount of taxation, then they are already an integrated part of the empire: congratulations!
They'd likely have an assigned Imperial posting to ensure they have access to the Imperial Examinations and study curriculum, and a provincial magistrate to formally report on those local disputes which threaten to become more than local - and to provide a non-partisan third party for dispute negotiations
(As a sidenote: it's pretty expensive to collect taxes from Xiongnu, so the Empire normally attributes an annual Census and Taxation period for the northern provinces.)
IF we assume all the above to be true, then there are few issues at all.
But, nothing's that easy, so I'm going to open the floor to you so you can pick holes in my neat little scenario

(20:45:37) Brokk: Well, it would be the druids that the reps were dealing with, and since they tend to be the better educated they would have little issue with examinations, though in unofficial matters and their own ceremonies they would use their own tongue. Since the youngers have to travel to gain experience they'd probably be taught the language and the bare minimum they'd need to pass. Does that work? Otherwise it's fine.
(20:46:41) Brokk: Edited the first post by the way and dropped all Bar the Dar Ohk.
(20:46:48) Darrik: Aye. If you read Bataar's app like I suggested, you'd see that the Xiongnu nomads have similar circumstances, and some tribes still resent having to use the Imperial language
(20:47:15) Darrik: Remember, World Dev setting info is about the general baseline of circumstances, not the exceptions
(20:47:23) Darrik: The exceptions are where the fun RP happen
(20:47:34) Brokk: Yes. It's on my reading list, I have it bookmarked with the others you sent me.
(20:49:28) Brokk: That could make for more interspecies conflict between their own clans too, as some less flexible or else just the ones that live outside the bureaucracy resent the others for giving in
(20:49:47) Darrik: So, as citizens of Tian Xia the Dar would be free to travel the empire if they wished, and could afford it. They would be free to seek out business dealings if logistics from their remote location allowed for it. They'd probably find their principal source of trade would be one of the northern trade cities (set up specifically to trade with the Xiongnu/Dar/etc)
(20:50:20) Darrik: Aye - the same applies to the Xiongnu. In fact, it was just that kind of RP that Bataar and Abagha were to embark on when Corey went on indefinite hiatus
(20:51:48) Brokk: Well, I was thinking more go to hell or go to connaught, so the ones that wouldn't agree were told to go West and not trouble people again.
(20:53:12) Brokk: But yeah, that all sounds good.
-
(20:54:55) Brokk: They regularly engage in Highland games style contests too to determine which clans are better, if that interests you at all.
(20:55:04) Darrik: Cool
(20:56:17) Darrik: I've added the chatlog into the world dev thread as well
(20:56:23) Brokk: The general idea is they'd travel when they were young, earn their scars, gain some experience and then go home and raise a family
(20:56:35) Darrik: I like that
(20:57:09) Darrik: Any citizen can apply for time spent in the Tian Xia military
(20:57:33) Darrik: It'd be interesting if the Dar did that sometimes, because it's something the Xiongnu in general refuse to out of principal
(20:57:47) Darrik: And might play into the Dar/Xiongnu tensions a bit as well
(20:58:47) Brokk: Family life starts with a marriage, where they are given a gift of a home and some livestock by their adopted clans, which they are expected to tend to and use to give back to the community and so forth
(20:59:48) Brokk: And yes, all the better if they could be grouped together and compete with one another.
(21:00:50) Brokk: Those who have lost their honour or have been exiled as criminals would likely sign on for life.
(21:00:52) Darrik: Aye. The Tianlong Generals would likely do that, given the difference in physique. A kind of crack infantry unit
(21:01:06) Darrik: Well, criminals wouldn't get into the army
(21:01:26) Brokk: Probably make good scouts too.
(21:01:46) Darrik: If a Dar is flagged as a criminal and leaves their territory, that information would be reported via the Magistrates
(21:02:08) Darrik: If they didn't turn themselves in for appropriate punishment for the crime they'd committed, they'd be hunted down
(21:02:18) Brokk: Well, criminal is a broad term, but I mean as a character origin,one might lie about that to escape justice etc.
(21:02:25) Darrik: Probably by the Jinyiwei if deemed to difficult for regular magistrates to handle
(21:03:20) Brokk: Especially since the punishment is usually exile for a period of penance or achieving some goal set by the druids.
(21:03:50) Darrik:
http://www.tharshaddin.com/wiki/The_Laws_of_Tian_Xia
(21:04:02) Brokk: For murder and such the punishment is death though so any assistance would be appreciated.
(21:04:02) Darrik: The Dar would have to abide by those on top of their own laws.
(21:04:36) Darrik: Particularly those leaving their own home villages and towns
(21:04:56) Darrik: So it wouldn't be a case of 'You're a criminal, sod off elsewhere now'
(21:05:10) Brokk: So there would be emphasis on ensuring that such matters did not come to imperial attention if possible.
(21:05:19) Darrik: If they were wanting to 'exile' a criminal, they'd have to turn the criminal over to the Imperial Law system
(21:06:11) Darrik: You might want to take some time to describe those internal Dar laws in more detail. I get the impression you and I are working off different understandings of criminal here
(21:06:29) Brokk: Okay. Though they could give him a head start and say he/she 'escaped custody'
(21:07:02) Darrik: That kind of duplicity would have been stamped out hundreds of years ago through sanctions and boycotts
(21:07:41) Brokk: Well, most matters are dealt with within the clans
(21:07:46) Darrik: Dar don't blend into crowds easily, so 'escaping into the general populace of Tian Xia' just wouldn't work, you know?
(21:08:09) Darrik: So what you'll need to do first is figure out which crimes call for 'exile'
(21:08:25) Darrik: Then we need to see if any of those crimes are punishable/enforcable under Imperial Law
(21:08:52) Darrik: That would then determine what kind of existing agreement would likely have been arranged between the two, hundreds of years prior to present day
(21:09:09) Brokk: Yes, but the point is that what happens to them is their own problem after that. Exile means no longer part of a clan. No family.You're no longer a person and no clan hold will receive you.
(21:09:51) Darrik: If they break a law in Dar Territory, it is still breaking the law within Imperial territory
(21:10:16) Brokk: I know.
(21:10:25) Darrik: But we are debating on thin air here: please work out which crimes call for exile
(21:10:40) Darrik: Then we can actually discuss them, rather than theorising, y'know?
(21:11:19) Brokk: indeed. Not murder, obviously those people would be hunted down and beheaded.
(21:12:30) Brokk: Stealing from the clan would be, so you would be exiled until you could replace the items stolen, but again that could only be the tradition.
(21:13:15) Brokk: Even if they served time under Tian Xian law they would still have that debt to repay.
(21:13:36) Darrik: Please read this:
http://www.tharshaddin.com/wiki/The_Laws_of_Tian_Xia
(21:13:46) Darrik: There is no 'serving of time'
(21:14:22) Brokk: So say, they would submit to imperial justice and once released would have to fulfil that social obligation. Again, thinking aloud.
-
(21:23:22) Darrik: To make life easier: the crimes which would make it impossible for a Dar to join the military are any which result in branding/tattooing
(21:23:43) Darrik: The Empire doesn't have a personal investment in how the Dar handle petty crimes
(21:23:52) Darrik: It's the major crimes the Magistrate keeps tabs on
(21:24:10) Darrik: Tian Xia doesn't want Dar murderers or rapists roaming free as you can imagine
(21:24:35) Darrik: And serial offenders for the pettier crimes get tattooed or branded according to the crime
(21:24:57) Darrik: Again, see that link I gave you
(21:25:01) Brokk: Then barring murder and anything serious they'd likely beat them senseless and give them the equivalent of don't come back til you've learned your lesson
(21:26:02) Brokk: So rapist, murderers, serial thieves would likely be killed Unless imperial law required otherwise.
(21:26:12) Darrik: Hmm. And if that has been going on for a few centuries, chances are there'd be a tacit understanding between the military recruitment office, the Dar magistrate, and the Dar druids
-
(21:27:24) Darrik: The tattoos/brands are identical throughout the empire
(21:27:55) Darrik: So that any official or citizen can recognise a criminal and be wary of their intentions
(21:28:53) Brokk: that works, though depending on what they did the Dar may request a druid be present or that the head be returned to them. I meant because they may not be readily visible on their skin is all.
(21:29:56) Darrik: That would depend on how far away it occurred.
(21:30:51) Darrik: The northern military would have an ongoing arrangement and understanding. Anywhere south of the Xiongnu steppes, not so much
(21:30:56) Brokk: They understand that. But the main thing is that they are seen to ask.
(21:32:15) Brokk: The head is the soul to them, so murderers should have to pay theirs in return the one they took.
(21:32:50) Brokk: Not always possible, but as long as they can say they tried that's enough.
(21:34:18) Darrik: Ja. At this point though we're at risk of getting bogged down in minutiae
(21:34:30) Darrik: So I again recommend going back to the broader strokes on the canvas
(21:35:28) Brokk: Yes, but generally they will abide by their obligations under imperial law with little complaint and then administer their own laws afterwards.
(21:35:42) Brokk: That work?
(21:36:31) Brokk: Imperial officials will be informed as to the status of and circumstances behind exiles and
(21:36:59) Brokk: Such to ensure proper understanding.
(21:37:29) Darrik: Honestly, unless you are actually planning to make a criminal character, a lot of this is unnecessary complication.
(21:37:56) Brokk: It is, but it's all worth knowing in case shit happens
(21:38:13) Darrik: It can be boiled down to the broad stroke of 'The Dar abide by Imperial Law, but also have their own cultural practices as follows: Z,Y,Z
(21:38:44) Darrik: The general approach the mods recommend is 'If it happens, work it out then, in case the RP points to an even more interesting solution'
(21:38:48) Brokk: Fair enough.
(21:39:30) Darrik: That's why I kept the Law section in Tian Xia very broad in scope, rather than say 'X strikes for X crime' and so forth
(21:40:09) Darrik: So long as the extremes are catered for to set the basic parameters, that's all that matters